I was talking about the Republic being in power before the movie. Destroying that crowded planet (Coruscant?) along with its neighbours was the first time SKB was used afaik. So the Republic could've well been in charge those 30 years since ROTJ and interfered with any huge building projects of the Empire like SKB.
Rey being Luke's daughter was my first thought, too, but then I was thinking about why he would leave her alone on a planet with nobody she or even he knows. If you remember the scene with her exchanging tech parts for food, she basically gets ripped off and barely gets enough food to survive. When that alien offers her 60 rations for BB8 (she previously got a quarter only), she was almost desperate enough to trade the droid in. So I'm wondering if Luke would really leave her there stranded and barely surviving for years. We know Luke isn't evil and I'm pretty sure he knows people who would've taken her in. And if he didn't, then sure as hell his sister Leia would have known some people. Maybe there's a plausible explanation why she's on Jakku if she were indeed Luke's daughter.
I've heard good things about the animated series but haven't had the chance to watch it yet. The main thing with TFA is it's part of the main storyline of SW and that means it's a Skywalker story. Even George Lucas adhered to the formula, I described, in the prequels. There is a reason for that and maybe that reason is how the Force is so tightly connected with any member of the Skywalker family, thus making history repeat itself over and over. So while the plot of SW Rebels sounds intriguing, something similar wouldn't work with the main movies. I feel it would lose that SW essence if you know what I mean. It would sound and look like a SW movie, sure, but it'd be a story taking place somewhere in the SW universe. Thus it wouldn't make sense to name it Episode VII. It would feel a lot more like a reboot actually (think the new Star Trek). However, we will get non-main story SW movies. The first one to come out this year titled "Rogue One" and that will be completely different. And perhaps that is more up your alley if you want something different that's still SW. Also the Han Solo movie will come out after VIII. So that's another chance to see a different style of SW movie.
I don't think that VIII will be the same as TESB. Maybe the overall theme will be similar, that is the evil guys will gain the upper hand. But that's probably all. How the story will actually play out is to be seen.
I disagree with the Han Solo death. I like Han but his death felt right in that moment. Letting him live would feel half-assed. It would feel like they're clinging to nostalgia instead of delivering a proper movie. It would be fan service and catering to fans and forcing the story to go off its natural progression.
Btw, I didn't think the movie was the same "scene for scene". The major plotpoints are the same obviously (see formula) but the scenes themselves were vastly different. For one, we got more scenes of the Empire and the stormtroopers up close, we also have a fugitive stormtrooper who's in many scenes of the movie and interacts with our heroine, which is absolutely different from ANH and Rey herself is independent and capable enough to do stuff on her own (she managed to escape on her own! Princess Leia had to be rescued...). Remember how Luke got on the Millenium Falcon the first time? He did nothing but sit around and ask questions. Most of the actions were done by Han and Chewie.
Imo TFA shines more in its details =) You should really re-watch it when it's out on Netflix.
no subject
Rey being Luke's daughter was my first thought, too, but then I was thinking about why he would leave her alone on a planet with nobody she or even he knows. If you remember the scene with her exchanging tech parts for food, she basically gets ripped off and barely gets enough food to survive. When that alien offers her 60 rations for BB8 (she previously got a quarter only), she was almost desperate enough to trade the droid in. So I'm wondering if Luke would really leave her there stranded and barely surviving for years. We know Luke isn't evil and I'm pretty sure he knows people who would've taken her in. And if he didn't, then sure as hell his sister Leia would have known some people. Maybe there's a plausible explanation why she's on Jakku if she were indeed Luke's daughter.
I've heard good things about the animated series but haven't had the chance to watch it yet. The main thing with TFA is it's part of the main storyline of SW and that means it's a Skywalker story. Even George Lucas adhered to the formula, I described, in the prequels. There is a reason for that and maybe that reason is how the Force is so tightly connected with any member of the Skywalker family, thus making history repeat itself over and over. So while the plot of SW Rebels sounds intriguing, something similar wouldn't work with the main movies. I feel it would lose that SW essence if you know what I mean. It would sound and look like a SW movie, sure, but it'd be a story taking place somewhere in the SW universe. Thus it wouldn't make sense to name it Episode VII. It would feel a lot more like a reboot actually (think the new Star Trek).
However, we will get non-main story SW movies. The first one to come out this year titled "Rogue One" and that will be completely different. And perhaps that is more up your alley if you want something different that's still SW. Also the Han Solo movie will come out after VIII. So that's another chance to see a different style of SW movie.
I don't think that VIII will be the same as TESB. Maybe the overall theme will be similar, that is the evil guys will gain the upper hand. But that's probably all. How the story will actually play out is to be seen.
I disagree with the Han Solo death. I like Han but his death felt right in that moment. Letting him live would feel half-assed. It would feel like they're clinging to nostalgia instead of delivering a proper movie. It would be fan service and catering to fans and forcing the story to go off its natural progression.
Btw, I didn't think the movie was the same "scene for scene". The major plotpoints are the same obviously (see formula) but the scenes themselves were vastly different. For one, we got more scenes of the Empire and the stormtroopers up close, we also have a fugitive stormtrooper who's in many scenes of the movie and interacts with our heroine, which is absolutely different from ANH and Rey herself is independent and capable enough to do stuff on her own (she managed to escape on her own! Princess Leia had to be rescued...). Remember how Luke got on the Millenium Falcon the first time? He did nothing but sit around and ask questions. Most of the actions were done by Han and Chewie.
Imo TFA shines more in its details =) You should really re-watch it when it's out on Netflix.